Magnus Carlsen vs Hans Hiemann: Endgame of the Avenger or chess’s reality show?

Hans Niemann was by no means the stereotypical teenage chess Grandmaster. Modest, introverted – that’s not him. At 19, the frighteningly-talented American was outrageously outspoken, unapologetically boastful and audaciously irreverent.

He appeared in a tearing hurry to climb the game’s score chart – the Elo pyramid – that had the sport’s unquestionable GOAT,

31-year-old Norwegian Magnus Carlsen, on the prime. Taking part in round Europe for many of this yr, the journeyman had an unreal meteoric rise.

Holding his distance from the opposite travelling US youngsters, the self-made maverick had the unsettling aura of a lone-wolf about him. His uncombed hair and dreamy eyes went properly along with his rebellious picture. He was an outlier, the type who makes the highly effective doubt their invincibility.

In March this yr, on the very fashionable present The Perpetual Chess Podcast (TPCP), Niemann was requested about his affiliation with Carlsen. The 2 had hung out collectively, performed soccer and talked store. The younger challenger was additionally signed up and supported by Carlsen’s firm PlayMagnus, a enterprise enterprise, in accordance with New York Instances, that had 250 workers and a market capitalisation of near $115 million.

Magnus Carlsen watching Hans Niemann on the 2022 version of the Sinquefield Cup. (Picture: chessphotoshop.com)

“Did you search his recommendation?”, the TPCP host Ben Johnson, requested.

“If I ask him for recommendation, he would assume he’s higher than me. I would like him to really feel that I might be higher than him someday. I don’t need to give him that psychological fringe of concern. Magnus’ edge comes from his opponents being afraid of him,” Niemann mentioned in a chilly and calculated tone.

About 5 months later, Niemann obtained his “someday”. He obtained invited to a match the place, at the very least on paper, he regarded misplaced and depth. Within the firm of the world’s main prime 9 gamers, together with Carlsen, he was an oddball.

Magnus Carlsen. (File)

In Spherical 3, Niemann obtained his second. He sat throughout the board towards the world’s finest participant. The younger sniper lastly had his goal in sight. Pundits who adopted the sport say that the American that day was ultra-aggressive, virtually disrespectful in his play. A rattled Carlsen would lose, that too whereas enjoying with white.

Niemann’s post-match feedback had been hardly measured or modest. “I believe he appeared so demoralised dropping to an fool like me. Should be embarrassing for the World Champion to lose to me. I really feel unhealthy for him,” he would say.

As Niemann was twisting the knife, at Camp Carlsen weapons had been being sharpened.

Magnus Carlsen won’t defend his world championship title. (AP)

Carlsen struck again along with his now well-known cryptic Jose Mourinho meme tweet: ‘If I communicate, I’m in large bother.’ It was an apparent insinuation that Niemann had cheated. It was a “nudge-nudge, wink-wink” allegation. Reacting to the furore, chess.com, the world’s most frequented on-line platform, would un-invite Neimann from a forthcoming international chess match and likewise strike him off the web site.

Neimann, as anticipated, reacted. “I’m not going to let chess.com, Carlsen … merely slander my popularity.” he mentioned.

After which he mentioned one thing that modified the hue of the controversy. He mentioned he had cheated previously. “I needed to get some score to play stronger gamers, so I cheated in random video games on chess.com. I used to be confronted and I confessed and that was the only largest mistake of my life,” he mentioned.

So used to coping with items of contrasting colors, the chess world, straight away, painted the lead actors – one in black, the opposite in white.

The champion was white, the cheater black.


The favored narrative missed the shades of gray. Extremely dependable evaluation of Worldwide Grasp, statistical tutorial and world-renowned chess cheat cop, Professor Kenneth Regan confirmed that Neimann hadn’t cheated. There was no sample in his play that day that steered that he was aided by computer systems.

However that didn’t fairly wipe the chess board clear. American GM, Hikaru Nakamura, mentioned nobody doubted Neimann of dishonest in his defeat to Carlsen however it was the previous that was bothersome.

Chess. (File)

“I don’t imagine that anyone who’s had suspicions or mentioned issues, it pertains to the Sinquefield Cup (the place Neimann beat Carlsen). For those who take a look at the historical past of Hans over the past couple of years, he’s had in all probability essentially the most meteoric rise in the whole historical past of chess of any 17-year-old by far. … I believe quite a lot of grandmasters are positively suspicious,” he mentioned.

The pandemic time growth in on-line chess has seen a spike in dishonest price and it has made gamers paranoid. Chess.com would normally ban about 5,000 gamers every month in 2021 however in August this yr the depend had gone as much as 17,000. Carlsen’s snub to Niemann, many really feel, was his method of amplifying the frustration of the fraternity that needed motion towards those that had been bending guidelines and now coming into the highest echelon of chess.

Magnus Carlsen enjoys a recreation of soccer in Kolkata. (File)

However there was one other layer of intrigue. Chess.com was in merger talks with PlayMagnus, it’s a tie-up that pushes Carlsen in a conflict-of-interest maze.

There have been whispers about chess.com planning a rematch by reinviting Neimann for a mega face-off with Carlsen. For the first-time in many years, chess, not essentially the most riveting spectator sport, was getting unprecedented consideration from even those that assume that Sicilian Defence was in regards to the Corleones going to the mattresses when attacked by Sollozzos.

Who advantages most from this unprecedented international curiosity on this boxing-like chess rivalry? Was this chess’ foray into actuality TV? It’s a season of significant unverified allegations.

Who is that this man chargeable for this dramatic chess churn?


Niemann’s backstory may be very totally different from Carlsen’s. Not like the Norwegian chess rockstar, Niemann didn’t take pleasure in early success rising up. He’s a struggler with no fastened deal with. There are scratchy particulars about his mother and father within the public area, aside from the truth that Niemann has a Hawaiian-Danish ancestry.

He was born in San Francisco however the household moved to the Netherlands when Neimann was very younger. He would take up chess on the age of 8. It was a taunt from a trainer, writing him off as a chess participant, that noticed him take to the sport with vengeance.

Magnus Carlsen in motion. (File)

The Neimanns moved again to the US quickly after and this time settled within the suburb of Berkeley. It was a stroke of luck that they opted for the Bay Space, America’s chess bowl. The younger boy would frequent a restaurant that was well-known for its “espresso chess video games.” In a twist straight out of a film script, this was a blessing in disguise.

In TPCP, he shares the endearing story about him assembly his shock benefactor on the cafe. “There was this man who regarded like a homeless man however was actually rich. The man, in a hideous method potential, tries to look essentially the most run-down. However truly, he was a chess philanthropist. He paid for almost all of my classes,” mentioned Neimann.

Extra nuggets about Neimann’s inspiring journey shine from a Chess Life cowl story, titled The Street Grandmaster, that he himself wrote.

Magnus Carlsen gestures to a crowd in India. (File)

For higher chess prospects, the household moved to Connecticut. As soon as once more, Neimann needed to be the brand new boy in a brand new college. His mother and father insisted that he wanted to have a university training.

A scholarship at a reputed New York college got here by. His household of six couldn’t afford NY rents so the chess prodigy-cum- class topper needed to keep on his personal. Even for Neimann’s single-person lodging, he needed to work “20 to 30 hours every week educating chess”. He additionally was making an attempt to get right into a reputed school and that’s when the Harvard snub occurred. It’s a blow that makes him sarcastic.

“They rejected a 16-year-old who was residing alone, had his personal job, had a full scholarship from one of the best prep college within the nation, and had nice grades. I didn’t care about going to highschool. I simply needed to be accepted. I needed to reject them. Hey, nobody cares about Harvard, your college is only a Wall Avenue manufacturing unit,” says the obsessively-driven boy recognized to be delicate to snubs and rejections.

Magnus Carlsen performs a recreation of chess. (File)

Lastly, chess would get its unflinching focus. Streaming would give Neimann money to outlive on the circuit. He would turn into a monk in penance to expertise chess’ stratospheric heights. His typical day would begin at 6 am with an hour and a half of swimming. “After the swim, I’d put in 10 to 12 hours of chess a day,” he says. Being onerous on himself is one other trait, as Niemann says, “If I don’t end in Prime 10, I might be a failure in chess and failure in life”.

It is a battle the place the stakes are excessive. Neimann has set the bar method too excessive for him and he wouldn’t need to be remembered as a cheater.


In instances when the credibility of the sport is being questioned, Scottish GM Jacob Aagaard has written a provocative weblog. It’s been extensively forwarded amongst gamers and followers. Early within the piece, titled ‘Paranoia and Madness’, he talks about his affiliation with Niemann. The one-time camp mates have stayed in contact. Niemann at one level had additionally joined Aagaard’s academy. The piece will get into the thoughts of chess’ sharpest mind. He places to check Carlsen’s “good boy” picture and leans in the direction of Neimann.

Magnus Carlsen reacts after a recreation of chess.

He wrote: “Folks say that Carlsen doesn’t behave badly when he’s dropping in his Meltwater Tour to Praggnanandhaa. It’s partly as a result of it’s like Federer dropping a set. It’s partly as a result of Praggnanandhaa is deferential to Magnus. Hans is just not. Hans desires to kill the king. Needs to take the throne. He has no regret over this in any respect.” He put out a reminder that Carlsen hasn’t been essentially the most gracious loser. “’Magnus behaved like an entitled brat’ is at the very least an equally cheap concept. This isn’t new behaviour.”

This Carl-Niem affair places chess in a decent spot. A sport is barely pretty much as good as its credibility. On-line chess, the place Niemann admitted to dishonest, faces a critical regulation deficit.

If Carlsen harbours doubts about whether or not an opponent is dishonest, or that his previous indiscretions have gone unpunished, it’s the sport’s failure. An open, clear troubleshooting by FIDE as quickly because it obtained the whiff of the matter, might’ve prevented this saga. Needing to riff a Mourinho quote for a cryptic tweet – open to one million interpretations – factors to a surprising absence of a discussion board to lift his issues. And concurrently unfair on Niemann, who stays a sitting duck for hypothesis.

Issues obtained difficult additional when Carlsen mentioned, “I’ve to say I’m very impressed by Niemann’s play and I believe his mentor GM Maxim Dlugy have to be doing an important job.” Dlugy, by the best way, was banned by Chess.com in 2017. The rationale: Dishonest.

Chess for now faces the basic endgame scenario. Gamers recognized to assume forward, plan a number of steps upfront, aren’t recognized to do issues within the warmth of the second. The items that had been as soon as on the board appear to have come alive and stepped off the board to be in the true world. The world waits for them to decide on the squares they might transfer to – white or black.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *